Josh Bauer

Josh Bauer

Nov 13, 2023

I didn't say Palestinians have a right to the land. I said they have a right to fight for it. But doing so comes with consequences if they're not able to win.

If you are going to make a moral or religious argument for Palestine being "entitled" to reside there, you run into the fact that Israel has equal historical ties and religious significance.

And while I do support Israel in winning, I recognize the legitimacy of religious and historical claims from both groups, which is why I can sympathize with Palestinians "wanting their land back".

But you can't just try to take something by force that currently belongs to someone else and expect no resistance or opposition.

And yes, that argument can be equally applied to Israel. The difference is that Israel doesn't tend to start military campaigns without the ability to follow through.

If Hamas is unable to win this war due to lack of personnel, weapons, or popular support, then they should have refrained from starting it instead of starting it then trying to solicit world sympathy for not being able to finish it.